[Varian Fry Institute Home] [Chambon Foundation Home]
See also Varian's War By Those Who Know
A few reference sources:
Robert A. Rosenstone, Visions of the Past: The Challenge of
Film to Our Idea of History (Harvard University Press, 1995)
Leger Grindon, Shadows on the Past (Temple University
Press, 1994)
Robert Brent Toplin, History By Hollywood: The Use and Abuse
of the American Past (University of Illinois Press, 1996)
Marc C. Carnes, editor, Past Imperfect: History According to
the Movies (Henry Hold and Co., 1995)
Carlin Romano, Accuracy:
a Novel Notion in Historical Novels? The Chronicle of Higher Education,
April 13, 2001.
Press references (excerpts):
The
Los Angeles Times, April 21, 2001
Full
Review by Daryl H. Miller (hyperlink lost)
Noble intentions aside, Varian's War... is a mess of a movie that leaves
viewers with more questions than answers about Varian Fry....Clumsily
constructed and hollowly acted, it's a project that its lead performers--William
Hurt and Julia Ormond--along with Barbra Streisand's Barwood Films, should
quickly try to bury in their resumes....Writer-director Lionel Chetwynd fudges a
lot of facts, beginning with the implication that Fry founded the Emergency
Rescue Committee. Chetwynd also plays fast and loose with depictions of the
supporting characters, including Fry's associate, Miriam Davenport
(Ormond), and
the writer Lion Feuchtwanger. The storytelling, meanwhile, is often
confusing, as when the married Fry stumbles upon a gay bar--included for no
discernible reason. And what isn't confusing is outright boring: Even the
hurried flight to the Spanish border comes across as little more than a casual
hike in the woods. With his hair crazily curled and his face perpetually
pinched, Hurt portrays Fry as a stuffy, prissy intellectual--a relentlessly
one-note performance.
The
Chronicle of Higher Education, April 20, 2001
Debasing Good History with Bad Fiction,
by
Peter I. Rose
Now,
six decades after the fact, Showtime Networks presents Varian's War,
offering a Hollywood tribute to the extraordinary feat of an American
Pimpernel....In the Showtime film, the producers make
an earnest attempt to tell the story of a homegrown hero still unknown to most
Americans. Unfortunately, what they have wrought does not do justice to
the man, his colleagues, or his cause.....Although
[director Lionel] Chetwynd's interpretation of [Varian] Fry's story contains kernels of
truth, his film is filled with errors of fact
about how the Emergency Rescue
Committee and the mission got started, about Fry and his aides, about the
selection process, about the role of the French and German authorities....Varian’s War is not
cinéma vérité,
despite the claim of its producers and publicists that theirs is the true story.
Those familiar with what actually happened will find the historical distortions
inexcusable and are bound to wince at the caricaturing of the rescuers and
asylum-seekers.
This review is not online except for Chronicle subscribers, who may access
it at Who
Was Varian Fry? (The Chronicle of
Higher Education).
The New York
Times, April 21, 2001
Varian's
War: A Pantheon of Artists Rescued From Hitler, by Anita Gates
Oskar Schindler became Liam
Neeson in an Oscar-winning Steven Spielberg movie in 1993. Raoul
Wallenberg was played by Richard Chamberlain in an Emmy-nominated 1985
television film. Now Varian
N.B. The Varian Fry rescue mission was not
focused on Jews, and the approximation of 2,000 people
helped includes many non-Jews, such as the German and Austrian anti-Nazi exiles
who were at the time among the most threatened by the fall of France.
Marcel Duchamp, Max Ernst, Heinrich Mann were not Jewish. Varian Fry was not rich.
It is not clear on what basis Julia Ormond's character is being defined as a
composite character: there was a real "Miriam Davenport" and the only
other American woman who worked with Varian Fry was Mary Jayne Gold--who bears
no relation to Ormond's character.
P.S. from The New York Times, May 3, 2001: A television review on April 21 about
Varian's War, a film on Showtime about the efforts of Varian Fry, an American, to save European artists and intellectuals from the Holocaust, misstated the religious affiliation of some notable figures he rescued. Marcel Duchamp, Max Ernst and Heinrich Mann were not Jews.
N.B. Let's try again. Fry was not exclusively or even
specifically seeking to help Jews, and thus was not attempting "to save
European artists and intellectuals"--and others--" from the
Holocaust." He was attempting to save anti-Nazis--many but no means
all of them Jewish--from the Nazis. The Times' correction leaves
uncorrected the statement that "some 2,000 European Jews" were helped
by Fry; that approximation by Fry of the number of people helped included many
non-Jews.
P.P.S from The New York Times, May 11, 2001: Because
of an editing error, a television review on April 21 about Varian's War,
a film on Showtime about an American who saved European artists and
intellectuals from the Holocaust, was abridged in a way that altered the
reviewer's meaning. The affected passage, with the restored phrase shown by
brackets, should have read: "As for Varian Fry, he did not go on to a
brilliant journalistic or foreign service career after the war. When he died in
1967 at 59, he was teaching high school Latin in Connecticut."
The
Jewish Week (New York), April 20, 2001
Full
Review by George Robinson
Out of this potentially fascinating,
possibly thrilling material, Chetwynd has fabricated a
cumbrous, sleep-inducing melodrama that recalls the worst of World War II
Hollywood propaganda features, with sneering, evil Nazis and Vichy French and
good guys who range from the noble to the picturesque, saving intellectuals who
are either cute and cuddly or young and sexy.
In order to achieve this dubious end, Chetwynd must vastly oversimplify Fry’s
motivations and blur his background while simultaneously spending an
unconscionable amount of screen time on the inessential throat-clearing of
lengthy speeches about freedom and the necessity of intellectuals that seem to
have been lifted from a 1943 Joan Crawford epic, all of which he gives a
lugubrious pace calculated to induce narcolepsy in the most severe sufferer from
Attention Deficit Disorder....Varian’s War has
the distinction of being a fairly complete catastrophe. To add to the
catatonic direction and wildly out-of-tune acting, the film has the hermetically
sealed look of a total studio product. The streets of Marseilles and Berlin have
never been so clean, so utterly devoid of life. Even the wall graffiti is neat
and ordered, as befits a film that lacks
even the slightest semblance of reality.
N.B. This reviewer is hard on 1943 Joan Crawford
epics, some of which were fun.
People, April
23, 2001
Review by
Terry Kelleher, television critic
Unfortunately this drama brings Fry's
story to our attention without bringing it fully to life....The talented William
Hurt gives a mannered performance....Fry's able aide, a composite figure played
by Julia Ormond, has two salient features: sexual candor ("I collect
special men") and a persistent cough....Neither is particularly
convincing. Viewers are meant to appreciate the climax--an uphill hike to
the Spanish border by winded artists and intellectuals--as the moral equivalent
of The Great Escape. Mentally I did, but not emotionally. Bottom
Line: Historical disappointment.
TN.B. Ormond is given the real-life name,
although not the character or appearance, of Miriam Davenport, and this is no
"composite figure": There were only two
American women who worked with Fry, Davenport and her friend, the beautiful heiress Mary
Jayne Gold. Nothing in the portrayal of "Miriam
Davenport" reflects Mary Jayne Gold--and little of importance reflects Miriam
Davenport...
The
San Franciso Chronicle, April 20, 2001
Full
Review by John Carman (see
below review of Meet the Pandas)
Varian's War is based, however loosely,
on the true story of Varian Fry, a wealthy American who went to Vichy, France,
during World War II and rescued 2,000 artists, writers and intellectuals from
Nazi persecution....William Hurt coughs up another curiously phlegmatic
performance as Fry....Produced by Barbra Streisand, the movie offers a stock
assortment of Nazi villains -- not that we're expecting Nazi heroes -- French
collaborators and bureaucratic American foot-draggers. There's some
derring-do, but little palpable suspense. It's on a par with broadcast network
movies and modestly entertaining, at best.
N.B. Varian Fry was not wealthy, just an
intellectual working stiff, but it's not surprising the reviewer got this idea
from the outlandish extravagance of the lifestyle Varian's War indicates
Fry engaged in.
The
Wall Street Journal, April 20, 2001
Reportedly
favorable review, available only for a fee online.
The
Hollywood Reporter, April 19, 2001
Full
Review
by Marilyn Moss
While the teleplay, written
by director Lionel Chetwynd, is often slow and simple, [star William] Hurt
redeems its shortcomings by delivering an intelligent and thought-provoking
character. Hurt seems far more intelligent than the
script, which insists
on distilling the story to its lowest common denominator.
N.B. The review refers to Fry deciding to
help "intellectual Jews including Marc Chagall, Heinrich Mann, Hannah
Arendt, Franz Werfel, Alma Werfel and others escape to the United
States." Heinrich Mann and Alma Werfel were not Jewish.
Daily
Variety, April
20, 2001
Full
Review
by Steven Oxman
What a strange collection of players we have here.
Showtime's Varian's War is exec produced by Edward Wessex, better known
as Prince Charles' brother, and another type of royalty in Barbra Streisand.
What they've come up with is a quality offering that turns an unheralded figure
into a cinematic hero, a good -- but could have been great -- story about an
American intellectual who in unlikely fashion helped prominent artists escape
Vichy France....
Fry is an unlikely figure for such a task, since he comes across as an effete
and ineffectual personage -- even his sexuality is subtly questioned. What's
clever about director Lionel Chetwynd's teleplay and Hurt's performance is that
they capture the way Fry used this perception to his advantage, evading the
watchful eyes of the French and German authorities by engaging them with a
foppish front....
The storytelling doesn't proceed with enough sharp clarity, however, to give it
the excitement that seems inherent in the tale....It's better as a character
study, and the scenes where Fry puts on his "Who me?" act to his
antagonists provide Chetwynd with his bread and butter, the quieter scenes of
political intrigue. But even here, the piece avoids rather strenuously
questioning the snobbishness that places some people's lives, artists in
particular, over others, and therefore never emerges as a deeper contemplation
on the Holocaust. To make matters worse, the artists themselves are depicted
with a touch of buffoonishness.
N.B. What's clever about the teleplay and
Hurt's performance, according to this reviewer, is that "they capture
the way Fry used [an alleged perception of him] to his
advantage." The reviewer here obviously assumes that Fry actually did
what the writer/director says he did--but Fry didn't! This is a complete
and utter fabrication that nobody who knew Fry or has studied the mission will
substantiate. Should "poetic" license be allowed to extend this
far, snaring even the savvy reviewer?
As for the "snobbishness" of the Fry mission, if the reviewer is left
with that impression, than Varian Fry's greatness is not here celebrated very
effectively.
The
Christian Science Monitor, April 20, 2001
TV
film honors the "American Schindler," by
M. S. Mason
A man named Varian Fry was one of the unsung heroes of
World War II. Now an excellent made-for-TV movie finally celebrates this
"American Schindler."...
"Varian Fry's enemies were not the Nazis," says writer and director
Lionel Chetwynd, "they were the French fascists. There was a vast and
elaborate collaboration between the French and the Germans at the level of the
state and among ordinary people.... Fry was thrown out of unoccupied France by
the French for aiding Jews and other anti-Nazis."
Fry was a wealthy New Yorker, who had grown up in Europe. A Harvard graduate and
a Christian, he numbered among his friends Christian theologian Reinhold Niebuhr,
who helped plan the actions of the Emergency Rescue Committee.
N.B. It is historically incorrect that Varian Fry's main
enemies were the Vichy French, or that Vichy in 1940 was run by "French
fascists"; Fry's main enemy was the State Department and the U.
S. consular corps in Marseille. Indeed, while it is true that Vichy
expelled Fry, this was done at the request of the U. S. Consul General in
Marseille, who may have received instructions to that effect from
Washington. The French were far less reluctant to see all these refugees
leave than the Americans were to receive them.
As stated earlier, the depiction of Vichy rule in Marseille
in Varian's War is essentially fanciful. Varian
Fry was not wealthy, just an intellectual working stiff, but it's not surprising
this reviewer too got this idea from the outlandish extravagance of the
lifestyle Varian's War indicates Fry engaged in. Fry did not grow
up in Europe. It's not clear what is meant by "Christian"
in this context; Varian Fry was not a practicing Christian.
The
Baltimore Sun, April 21, 2001
Complex
fight for freedom, by
David Zurawik, television critic
(hyperlink lost)
Showtime is promoting Varian's War, its new film
about an American intellectual who saves Jewish intellectuals from Hitler's
Europe, as "the true story of the American Schindler." Given the
immense popularity and revered status of Schindler's List, who can blame
Showtime for trying to forge that link in viewers' minds? But in some ways
(and I know some readers are never going to believe me), Varian's War
is a more interesting and enlightened film than
Schindler. The more
interesting part involves a fascinatingly quirky and cerebral lead performance
by William Hurt as Varian Fry, an American magazine editor appalled by Nazi
barbarism who decides to do something about it at a time when much of the rest
of America looked the other way during the late 1930s....[What's] important
about the Jewish characters in Varian's War is that they are not depicted
one-dimensionally as victims and objects of pity. The Jews here, who range from
painter Marc Chagall (Joel Miller) to writer Hannah Arendt (Elyzabeth Walling),
are highly individualistic and, in a couple of cases, even a little abrasive in
their opinions and intellectual snobbery....The finest supporting turn...is that
of Julia Ormond, whose character humanizes Fry and sets the great-escape plot
into motion....Chetwynd takes the time early on to let us get a good long look
at Fry, and this is important because he is a not a character who is easy to
like. In fact, in less talented hands than those of Chetwynd and Hurt, Fry might
be inaccessible to a mainstream audience. But Hurt plays Fry as a man who
seems more engaged in a private dialogue with his inner self than with the
outside world, and it makes the character fascinating. You want to know what
makes him tick. And once Chetwynd moves Fry to Nazi-occupied Marseille, you are
on the edge of your seat wondering how this intellectual who seems tailor-made
for the role of an absent-minded professor is going to beat the Nazis and
smuggle these towering figures of European culture to safety. It is no
secret that Showtime desperately wants to be thought of as an equal of HBO when
it comes to being a maker of the very best made-for-TV movies. A few more
productions like "Varian's War," and Showtime might just make it.
The
Houston Chronicle, April 20, 2001
Disappointing tribute to
a war hero, by Ann Hodges, television critic
The movie...is also debuting [April
20, 2001] at the WorldFest -
Houston International Film Festival. Between director Lionel Chetwynd's sketchy script and
Hurt's off-putting,
too-precious performance as a kind of contemporary Scarlet Pimpernel, Varian's
War never quite stirs the emotions it should....In Marseilles, swastika banners
are everywhere, and, as this indicates, the Vichy French are working
hand-in-steel-glove with the Germans to make sure these refugees don't get
away....[The] "soul keepers of
Western Europe" come across here like a bunch of naughty and foolish
children. Julia Ormond gets a somewhat better break as Varian's invaluable
aide, Miriam Davenport. The name is real but the character is a composite.
Matt Craven plays Albert Hirschman, a Jewish refugee who volunteers his services,
and he's a real person. Hirschman is now the former head and professor emeritus
of Princeton's Institute for Advanced Study....His was a noble
cause, but Varian's War is an unsatisfying effort to pay it
tribute. Grade:
B-.
N.B. Swastika banners were not on display in
Vichy France; the distinction between Vichy France and German-occupied
Northern France is lost on the filmmakers. "[Miriam Davenport's]
name is real but the character is a composite." There were only two
American women who worked with Fry, the beautiful heiress Mary
Jayne Gold being the other. Nothing in the portrayal of "Miriam
Davenport" reflects Mary Jayne Gold--and little reflects Miriam
Davenport...
Ventura
County Star, April 22, 2001
Journalist saves Jews in Varian's
War, by John Crook, DV Data Features Syndicate
Oscar winner William Hurt portrays Fry in Varian's
War, a fascinating Showtime
movie. The son of a wealthy New York family, Fry happened to be
traveling through Germany as a journalist in the 1930s and personally
witnessed Kristallnacht, when Nazis smashed the windows of Jewish
establishments....It's important to note that Fry was no Scarlet Pimpernel, a
dashing desperado posing as a milquetoast. He truly was a self-effacing
intellectual who steeled himself to overcome almost impossible odds simply to
do the right thing. "Rarely have I come across ... an individual
who struck me as truly modest," Hurt said. "He was such a
self-effacing personality that he got lost."
N.B. Mr. Hurt's research into the real Varian
Fry was obviously limited: nobody who knew Varian Fry ever described him as
"truly modest." And far from being "self-effacing,"
the real Varian Fry could be rather ornery. The real Varian Fry,
contrary to what the reviewer mistakenly asssumes is the truth, did not
witness Kristallnacht.
The
Jerusalem Post, April 12, 2001
US movie dramatizes
righteous gentile by Tom Tugend, JTA, also published in
The Jewish
Journal of Greater Los Angeles, April 19. 2001
Saving
Europe's Soul by
Tom Tugend
The
Jewish Journal of Greater Los Angeles, April 19. 2001
Hollywood
and the Holocaust by Sally Ogle Davis
(hyperlink lost)
Some stories have taken 60 years to tell, like Varian’s
War, a tale that director Lionel Chetwynd is convinced was suppressed for
reasons of diplomacy. Varian’s enemy was not the Nazis, but the Vichy French.
And until recently in the popular wisdom (and on the screen, with the notable
exception of Casablanca) the French were our freedom-loving,
resistance-fighting allies, rather than an important part of the Nazi plan to
exterminate the Jews.
N.B. As stated above, it is historically incorrect that Varian Fry's main
enemy was the Vichy French; his main enemy was the State Department and the U.
S. consular corps in Marseille. The depiction of Vichy rule in Marseille
in Varian's War is essentially fanciful. It is a shame that neither
of the two articles cited above address the issue of just what liberties are
acceptable in adapting history for the screen, especially when the claim is made
that the movie is based on a "true" story.
My
TV TAXI (online)
Varian’s War:
a WWII Mission Impossible by Stephany Wilson
The
Weekly Standard, March 19, 2001
Round One to Bush by
Fred Barnes (opening paragraph only)
On the evening before the vote in the House on the most important part of his
most important initiative -- the $ 1.6 trillion tax cut -- President Bush
watched a movie. He invited leaders of Jewish organizations and Jewish members
of Congress to join him in the 40-seat White House theater for a screening of Varian's
War. The movie is about Varian Fry, an American who engineered the escape
of Jewish artists and intellectuals from Vichy France in World War II. Bush sat
with Lionel Chetwynd, the movie's director and one of Hollywood's few
conservatives and Bush supporters. Bush hung around for an hour afterwards,
chatting. The subject of taxes never came up.
© 2001, The Weekly Standard
Daily Variety,
March 9, 2001
RH'w'd Has a Friend in Oval
Office, Chetwynd sez by Army Archerd
GOOD MORNING: Remember you heard it here first -- "Hollywood has a friend in the White House." I told you on Wednesday that President George W. Bush was screening Showtime's "Varian's War" at the White House that evening, and here's the report from the film's writer-director, Lionel
Chetwynd. The President and First Lady thought the pic was "fantastic" and lingered an hour after the screening to talk about the making of the film, which centers on American hero Varian Fry, who rescued French Jewish artists from the Nazis in the South of France. Chetwynd said Bush wanted to know more about "the industry." In that discussion, "He also wanted to know more about the people who are making movies." Chetwynd says he became convinced: "We have a friend in the White House." Others viewing the Showtime movie (and not mentioned here Wednesday) include Hollywood GOP supporters Bruce Ramer (also national president of the American Jewish Committee) and Frank and Katherine Price. While in D.C., Chetwynd met with Democrat Sen. Joe Lieberman, an outspoken critic of violence in pix and TV. Chetwynd will arrange for him to be a guest of the Hollywood Caucus. "I'd disapprove if the government got involved (in ratings)," Chetwynd told me. "We should worry about that and we should address it before the government gets around to it."
Daily Variety,
March 7, 2001
World War II Redux by
Army Archerd
GOOD MORNING: It's showtime at the White House tonight. To be more
accurate it's Showtime's "Varian's War: A Forgotten Hero" screening
in the 45-seat theater. Invited by the President to the showing of the film,
which airs April 22, are Showtime's Matt Blank and Jerry Offsay, the film's
writer-director Lionel Chetwynd, costars Julia Ormond and Gloria Carlin, a few
members of Congress and reps of the American Jewish Committee, United Jewish
Communities and B'nai B'rith. Chetwynd is responsible for the print getting to
the White House. He's known the President for four years and "has
supported him" during the campaign and most recently was backstage at
"The Tonight Show" when Bush guested. He allows this screening is a
"tremendous gesture" by the President, "but it is good for the
film industry as well." Showtime chairman-CEO Blank, who allows he's
"an old Democrat," says the film is great and it's important that
the film get this exposure. It's about American Varian Fry, who risked his
life while rescuing French artists, including Chagall, from the French Vichy,
Nazi-controlled government, by taking them over the Pyrenees mountains.
Producers of the film include Barwood's Barbra Streisand and Cis Corman and
(Prince) Edward Wessex. The producers were not invited. Of course we know the
political party leanings of Streisand and Corman, but they weren't invited, I
was told, "because it (the screening) happened very quickly."
Politics aside, Chetwynd told me he and Corman worked together during the
entire production and Barbra was "very helpful with music cues" at
the finale of the film. Chetwynd is a longtime conservative (when Variety
reviewed his "Hanoi Hilton" on March 25, 1987, for example, reviewer
Lawrence L. Cohn said the story of U.S. prisoners during the Vietnam War
"emerges as a right-wing tract" and accused him of "taking
right-wing potshots that do a disservice to the very human drama of the
subject.") Chetwynd is now writing and will direct a PBS feature,
"The Carl Foreman Letter," about Foreman's heartbreak letter to the
N.Y. Times' Bosley Crowther, Aug. 7, 1952, recounting what happened to him
after he was called by HUAC. Chetwynd continues chronicling U.S. history on
film with the story of Eisenhower, the last few days before D-Day, and the
1704 "Deerfield Massacre," a feature for Col with Frank Price and
Alan Greisman producing.
©
2001,
Variety, Inc.
The
Washington Post, March 6, 2001
Column by Lloyd Grove
THIS JUST IN . . .
• The Weekly Standard's Fred Barnes was so impressed with
"Varian's War" -- a Showtime movie written and directed by
Brit-turned-American Lionel Chetwynd and starring William Hurt as
Varian Fry, a Harvard-educated American journalist who rescued 2,000 artists and
intellectuals from Nazi-occupied France -- that Barnes sent a video to White
House aide Karl Rove, who raved to President Bush, who scheduled a
White House screening for tomorrow night. Expected are Hurt's co-stars, Julia
Ormond and Lynn Redgrave, Chetwynd and his wife, actress Gloria
Carlin.
© 2001,
The Washington Post Company
[Varian Fry Institute] [Chambon Foundation Home]
[email us] [contact information] [table of contents] [make a contribution?] [search] [feedback] [guest book] [link to us?]
© Copyright 2006, Chambon Foundation. All rights reserved. Revised: June 25, 2006